• Help Support Hardline Crawlers :

building a home vs buying

jeeptj99

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 5, 2013
Messages
4,785
Reaction score
634
Location
Cleveland Tn
Looking to buy/build a house soon (already lining up credit and all that with the banks) and just wondering who has done one or the other and which one was the best. Some back ground might help:
Parents gave me 5 acres on their land where we had a house at one point (destroyed by tornados)
Have pretty good credit
Single income ATM but planning on roommates/gf living there to help out
Trying to keep it simple

I work in a lumber yard so getting material at a decent cost wont be an issue and I know a bunch of contractors because of my job. Just trying to figure out what would be my best choice.
Thanks
 
Sounds like you have some good options available to build. When I built mine my job allowed me to leave when I needed to go pick up lumber or answer questions at the house site. It was nearly a full time job trying to build it but was well worth it in the end.
 
Re:

Dude, if you have 5 acres and your single and you work at a lumber yard....... I think its a no brainer. Your lucky and its smart of you to be thinking of this now. I say build you something simple and most importantly, AFFORDABLE!!! Maybe a garage with an apartment above it with plans for a house later or something. Good luck with whatever you do.
 
You know what they say, you always end up with wayyyy more $$$ into it than what you initially planned for. Now if you can afford it, it doesn't matter. But if you decide to build and base your plan off of the max you can afford, it's likely to grow unaffordable before it's finished.

I have 2 good friends both married, that built new house over the past couple years and they ended up having to go back to the bank and borrowing more money after a month or two of building. Never fails. I intended on spending around $5k to build my little shop at my house, spent $7,500. I'm happy with it and it didn't hurt me too bad to spend that little extra to do it right, but the ratio is a little more when you're talking about the costs of building a house.

My best friend finally finished college and landed a good job this past year and ended up buying a house in a sub division down the road from mine last year. It was only a few years old and in great shape. Move in, no problems, worry free. He's done little things like build a sweet back deck on it, fire pit, and is about to have the whole driveway concreted. That's the way to go in my opinion, starting out. Buy one in good shape in your price range, then customize it to fit your needs. Then one day on down the road when you're making bank or get married and have another source of income, you can build the house of your dreams or whatever.

My house is small 2 bed 2 bath, but was only 3 1/2 years old when I bought it so it was still like new. I'm 27 years old and it has served me well for what will be 5 years this June. I do not plan to buy another house until I get married so the new house budget will be reflected from 2 sources of income....and yes, I am not marrying a bitch that don't work. Also being that I've been on my own for 5 years, my idea of what I want in a house has changed vastly. When I bought this house, I was just looking for a problem free, cheap to maintain, and cheap to operate home so I could get out of my parent's house. Location is not terrible, but my next house will be in a better location.

So over the years, you will think of all sorts of stuff you desire in a house and it's likely it will be very different than what's on your mind right now. My vote is buy a house that seemingly will hold a good resale value and live in it until you get ready to build.

Just my $0.02 from my experience and I know everyone is not like me. Just some of that "wish I knew then what I know now" sort of stuff.
 
Being a contractor myself, this is a question I have spent lots of time thinking about. with all the foreclosure stuff out there there are some good eals to be had if you can be patient. But if you have 5 acres that has some improvements on it already, I'd say build. Just be sure and watch the $ pretty close. Something I did for the first time was last year, when I built a house for some friends, was ask all the subs if they would like to discount for cash, most did. I bet they saved 5k on the project. Good luck!
 
Re:

tyldyl12 said:
Dude, if you have 5 acres and your single and you work at a lumber yard....... I think its a no brainer. Your lucky and its smart of you to be thinking of this now. I say build you something simple and most importantly, AFFORDABLE!!! Maybe a garage with an apartment above it with plans for a house later or something. Good luck with whatever you do.

ive thought about this since when i am home i am usually outside in the shop or just outside in general. i dont want anything super fancy just a place to call home and have all my toys haha. The only reason i am even considering the foreclosed homes is becasue there are some amazing deals in the area. I just hate the thought of living in a subdivision though.
 
Just got done building.................BUY!! BUY BUY BUY BUY BUY BUY BUY BUY BUY BUY :****: Unless you can build it with your own two hands BUY BUY BUY BUY BUY BUY BUY BUY. can't trust no one now a days to A) do a good job B) not try to rob you blind.
 
We just finished building a house last fall. It was the most miserable experience of my life. I will never do it again.
 
drkelly said:
We just finished building a house last fall. It was the most miserable experience of my life. I will never do it again.

This X1000!!!!!!!!!!!! BUY BUY BUY BUY BUY BUY BUY BUY
 
jeeptj99 said:
Just curious why was it so bad?

I don't think you understand just how much work it is until you actually go through it. You either can pay someone to arrange for everything to be done or save a lot of money and contract a lot of it out yourself....which is a huge headache in itself besides everything else.
 
TacomaJD said:
I don't think you understand just how much work it is until you actually go through it. You either can pay someone to arrange for everything to be done or save a lot of money and contract a lot of it out yourself....which is a huge headache in itself besides everything else.

My dad just finished building his new house. 7 days a week for 5 months, mostly by himself. He did hire an old man that needed work to give him a hand for a while but he wasn't a huge help. There were a lot of unexpected expenses that made him go over budget about half way into it. Last years record rains really didn't help things either. On the bright side, he did it right and had it appraised for almost double what he's got in it.

After being involved with that, there is no way in hell I would ever build my own house. Stressful is a understatement.
 
TacomaJD said:
I don't think you understand just how much work it is until you actually go through it. You either can pay someone to arrange for everything to be done or save a lot of money and contract a lot of it out yourself....which is a huge headache in itself besides everything else.

yeah i see your point. and the point about what i want in a house changing. other than the land being free i absolutly love where i live. im far enough away from everything that i can shoot a gun or do the no pants dance on my front porch, but still only like 10 min away from walmart and grocery stores.
 
Blase said:
Buy a double wide or modular home and put it on your land.

this isn't happening haha. I grew up in a double wide and all I remember through my childhood was my dad saying what a mistake it was. We had constant issues with that thing so I am going to stay away from double wides. I just want a house and some sort of stability before I get to serious with anyone and have a life halfway made for myself.
 
The shop/apartment is the best idea. Build it nice enough to live in for a few years and then when you get serious, build the house next door and move in it. The you will always have a house and garage.
 
bradzuki said:
The shop/apartment is the best idea. Build it nice enough to live in for a few years and then when you get serious, build the house next door and move in it. The you will always have a house and garage.


That's exactly what I did.

Bought ~11 acres

Built a 2500 sqft pole barn, 1/2 house 1/2 shop. 3 bedroom, 2 bath (one bathroom is in the shop portion). Finished the inside out like a cabin.

Had 2 roomates for 4? years or so.

Now I'm married and we did some little things to the inside to make it nicer for the wife.

We'll probably have kids here, and let them tear up the ShopHouse before we build another "real" house like she wants.

By the time we're ready for that, we'll have the current shophouse and land paid for, and can build whatever house we want.


Just make sure to build the shophouse on a part of the property with building another house in mind.
 
I just finished building my house last summer there is good and bad about building a house your self
Good:
1. You get exactly what you want in a house
2. You can save money "but the key word is can, you also can get screwed" make sure you get multiple quotes and anyone you do hire make sure you sign a contract and make sure you include timeline
3. You know everything there is to know about your house
4. You get to tell everyone you built it

Bad
1. Very very time consuming
2. Spend hours planning and setting up estimates
3. Babysit contractors and make sure that they are doing what they specified when the contract was signed
4. Sometime a general contractor will get better prices than you will be able to get due to you not having a presence in the contractor world
5. Lots of decision that have to be made on form and function and any changes are costly


All in all I loved how my place turned out and would never be able to find a place that would have fit all of the criteria that I was looking for so it made sense to me to build with that being said I do work in the Constuction industry so that was also a big role in my decision.
 
Back
Top