Originally Posted by Scott@Rockstomper
My Achilles heel with the 9": ARB locking collar. I beat the snot out of my stuff, with 40's, ~300hp, C6, ~45:1 crawl, sometimes 400+ pounds of ballast in my front tires, a nearly-4k-pound car (without ballast)... I was rough on stuff.
9" vs 60 in pictures (these are all ARB parts, nothing stock):
60 side gear, 9" side gear, 9" locking collar.
60 side gear sitting on 9" locking collar.
Flipped over, 9" side gear in its own locking collar.
Same thing, but with the 60 side gear sitting on the 9" locking collar.
If I'd not abused my rig in comp, the 9" stuff probably would've lived a good long while; if I'd treated it as a race car (put it on a maintainance schedule and torn down everything appropriately to preemptively fix stuff before it broke) it probably would've been fine in comp as well; if I'd put it on a diet, or gone to smaller tires, same thing, probably would've been fine.
Instead, I bigger-hammer'd it, went to 60's (that 60 side gear, is the standard 35 spline one; I went to 37 spline) and went on neglecting my own maintainance.